The sample was run April 14th and the results are saved in file BSA0414A.   The molecular weight (MW) was calculated by two independent approaches, 1) the "two detector" method and 2) by using the ASTRA software.   In the the "two detector" method, the MW is determined from a calibration curve obtained from a series of standard proteins.  This calibration determines the relationship between MW and the ratio of the light scattering (LS) and refractive index (RI) signals.  In the Astra approach, the MW is determined by solving the equation that relates the excess scattered light, measured at several angles, to the concentration of protein and the weight-average molar mass.  The results are summarized in Table 1.
 
 Table 1. Results of SEC-LS analysis for run BSA0414A.
 

 * A monodisperse peak is a peak that contains one type of molecule of defined MW (e.g., pure monomeric protein).  The peak is thus homogenous with respect to MW.  In the case of a  monodisperse peak, the average molar mass will be independent of the averaging method used and polydispersity will equal to 1.  If the peak contains a mixture of species of different molar masses (polydisperse peak; for example, a mixture of dimer [or tetramer] and monomer) the weight average molecular weight, Mw, will vary across the eluting peak and the average mass (for the entire peak) will change depending on the averaging method and  polydispersity will be greater then 1.

^a calculated from propagation of errors from calibration curve used and from noise in the LS and RI signal

The important findings from the SEC-LS/RI/UV analysis of BSA include:
 

• the BSA sample elutes as three peaks from the gel filtration column under the buffer conditions used during the chromatography (i.e., 20 mM HEPES, 100 mM KCl, 1 mM EDTA, pH=8.0) [see UV traces on Strip Chart View Plot ].

• the molecular weight of BSA protein in the eluting peaks is estimated as ~215 kDa for the smallest peak (<8% total mass), 139 kDa for the minor peak (~19% of total mass) and 66 kDa for the major peak (73% of total mass)  indicating that, under conditions used during the chromatography, the BSA sample was a mixture of a monomer and dimer with a small amount of higher order aggregates  [see Report from "two detector" analysis and Summary report from ASTRA].

• the weight average MW for the monomer and dimer peaks does not depend on protein concentration indicating that these peaks were monodisperse, i.e., contained one type of molecule of defined MW (homogeneous with respect to MW; see Distribution of Molar Mass).

• the molecular weights determined by both analyses, i.e., "two detector" method and ASTRA analysis, are in very good agreement [see Table 1].

•  Strip Chart View Plot with UV/RI and LS traces (peaks analyzed by "two detector" method are marked on UV trace).
• Report from "two detector" analysis.
• Calibration curve used for "two detector" method analysis.
• Peak ID Plot that contains superimposed signals from UV (AUX1; blue), RI (AUX2; green) and LS (signal from 90° detector; red) detectors (please note that the large LS signal at ~9 mL arises from "dust" impurities in the sample/injector.  Since the RI signal indicates this LS peak does not have any significant mass associated with it, this LS peak may be ignored,  the "negative/positive peaks" in the RI signal at the end of the run arise from salts/air in the injected sample).
• Summary report from ASTRA software (plus an ASTRA Summary Report Explanation Chart).
• Example of Debye/Zimm plot for a selected slice (maximum of the peak).
• Plot of Distribution of Molar Mass vs. elution time.

File BSA0414A: 100 mg loaded.

        As indicated on the UV trace shown on Strip Chart View Plot, your sample eluted from the gel permeation column in three peaks with the maxima at ~12.8 mL (peak #1), 13.8 mL (peak #2) and 15.5 mL (peak #3; major peak).  The mass distribution between these peak was: the major peak that eluted at ~15.5 mL contained  ~73 % of the total eluted mass, the minor peak that eluted at  ~ 13.8 mL represented ~19 % of the total mass and the smallest peak (~12.8 mL) contained less then 8 % of the total eluted mass.  Based on the LS and RI data, and the attached Calibration curve, the molecular weight was estimated by the "two detector" method as 233±36 kDa for peak #1,  141±9 kDa for peak #2 and 67±1  kDa for peak #3 (seeReport from "two detector" analysis).  The UV/RI ratio was identical, within the errors limits, for all three peaks indicating that they most likely contained different oligomers of the same polypeptide (see Report from "two detector" analysis).

 Peak ID Plot indicates the boundaries of  the peaks that were selected for molecular mass calculations using the ASTRA software.  The molecular masses calculated from the Debye plot are presented in the Summary report from ASTRA as Mn (number average molar mass), Mw (weight average molar mass) and Mz (z-average molar mass;  see Molar Mass Moments in ASTRA Summary Report Explanation Chart for details).  The average molecular weight was estimated as 215 kDa for peak #1, 137 kDa for peak #2 and 65.6 kDA for peak #3.  There was no variation in the molecular weight across peak #3 (see plot of Distribution of Molar Mass vs. elution time) indicating this peak was homogenous with respect to MW and contained only a monomer of BSA protein.  The MW for slices across peak #2 range from 130 kDa to 150 kDa indicating this peak contained a dimer of your protein that was separated from the monomer during gel permeation (see plot of Distribution of Molar Mass vs elution time).  This peak has not been fully separated from peak #1 and the estimated Mw is elevated at the regions where the peaks are overlaping (due to the fact that light scaterring is measuring Mw, the weight average molecular weight of all the species present in solution).  Peak #1 is clearly a polydisperse peak that contained a mixture of different oligomers with the Mw varying from 190 kDa to 240 kDa within the boundaries of the peak (see plot of Distribution of Molar Mass vs. elution time).

        The molecular weights determined by both analyses, i.e. "two detector" method and ASTRA analysis, are in good agreement (see Table 1).

 

Peak	max UV at  (mL)	UV	error	LS	error	RI	error	UV/RI	error	LS/RI	error	MW    (kDa)	error    (kDa)
#1	~12.8	0.005	0.001	0.036	0.002	0.007	0.001	0.7	0.2	5.1	0.8	233	36
#2	~13.8	0.012	0.001	0.056	0.002	0.018	0.001	0.67	0.07	3.1	0.2	141	9
#3	~15.5	0.046	0.001	0.113	0.002	0.077	0.001	0.60	0.02	1.47	0.03	67	1

 

 
 

Standard proteins	MW  (kDa)	LS/RI	MW calculated   from LS/RI calibration   (kDa)
Cytochrome C	12.3	0.25	11.33
Carbonic Anhydrase	29.0	0.65	29.2
Ovalbumin	43.2	0.95	42.6
BSA	66.3	1.47	66.5
Alcohol Dehydrogenase	147	3.18	144

 
AUX1  =   UV signal (absorbance at 280 nm;  blue)
AUX2  =   RI signal  (refractive index changes;  green)
90° Detector   =  LS trace recorded for the detector at 90° angle (highest scattering signal;  red)
                             (please note that the RI and UV signals are scaled to LS signal)

        Vertical lines indicate boundaries of peak/peaks selected for ASTRA analysis

File : C:\WTC\ASTRA450\RUNS3-~1\BSA0414A.ADF
Sample ID : BSA 100 ug in100 ul (750 loop) 20 mM HEPES, KCl 100mM, 1 mM EDTA  pH=8.0
Operator : Ewa
 

COLLECTION INFORMATION                                                                            

Collection time :             Tue  Apr 14, 1998  12:49 PM
Instrument type :            DAWN DSP
Cell type :                      K5
Laser wavelength :         632.8  nm
Solvent name :               water
Solvent RI :                   1.332
Calibration constants
     DAWN :                   3.0090e-05
     "AUX2" :                  2.1093e-04
Flow rate :                     0.400 mL/min

PROCESSING INFORMATION                                                                            

Processing time :                  Wed  May 27, 1998  01:24 PM
DAWN/AUX2 delay :         0.130 mL
Fit method / model :             Debye
Calculation method :            dn/dc + AUX Constant
Detectors used :                  6  7  8  9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16

RESULTS
                                                          PEAK #1                 PEAK #2                PEAK #3

Volume (mL) :                               12.650 - 13.220         13.620 - 14.313          15.127 - 16.483
Slices :                                                 172                             209                           408
A2 (mol mL/g&sup2;) :                     0.000e+00                  0.000e+00                  0.000e+00
Fit degree :                                         1                                1                                1
Injected Mass (g) :                        0.0000e+00               0.0000e+00              0.0000e+00
Calc. Mass (g) :                                  4.7522e-06               1.3333e-05               7.5068e-05
dn/dc (mL/g) :                                   0.184                         0.184                         0.184
Polydispersity(Mw/Mn) :               1.003±0.026               1.001±0.015             1.000±0.010
Polydispersity(Mz/Mn) :                1.005±0.045               1.002±0.026             1.001±0.017

Molar Mass Moments (g/mol)
 Mn :                                        2.149e+05 (1.8%)           1.365e+05 (1.0%)         6.558e+04 (0.7%)
 Mw :                                       2.154e+05 (1.8%)           1.366e+05 (1.1%)         6.561e+04 (0.7%)
 Mz :                                        2.160e+05 (4%)              1.367e+05 (2.4%)         6.563e+04 (1.5%)

R.M.S. Radius Moments (nm)
 Rn :                                             4.6 (190%)*                        5.1 (111%)                3.7 (161%)
 Rw :                                            4.8 (176%)                        5.3 (103%)                3.8 (150%)
 Rz :                                             5.0 (176%)                        5.5 (103%)                3.9 (150%)
 

* Please note that light scattering can be used to estimate size/radius of objects that are of the size that correspond to at least 1/20th of the incident light.

Upper panel: 

• Debye plot ;  a plot of  R(theta)/ K*c  vs  sin² (theta /2) and fit of a polynomial into the data to obtain the Mw from the intercept and radius from the slope at zero angle (see ASTRA Summary Report Explanation Chart for more details)

• RI  and  LS  traces with the peak boundaries marked by vertical lines; the short vertical mark "|" on the traces indicates the slice for which the Debye plot is shown.

 
The solid line/lines indicates the trace from RI detector while "dots" are Mw determined for each slice, i.e., every 3.3 microliter of the elution volume.

The ASTRA Summary Report contains information about the calculated molecular weights (MW) as well as collection and processing parameters that were applied during data analysis.

The following chart is designed to guide you through the Summary Report (adopted from ASTRA manual; Wyatt Technology).  Please note that the Result section presents data for ALL peaks selected for analysis.  Peak selection and boundaries are shown on the attached "Peak ID" graph.
 

COLLECTION INFORMATION

This part of the report contains information about data collection, instrument used, type of  flow cell in the LS detector and solvent in the mobile phase.

The values of the calibration constants used during data processing are shown along with the information regarding mass detector (refractive index or UV) was used to estimate eluted mass:
 

PROCESSING INFORMATION

 
This part of the report refers to the fitting method that was used by ASTRA to carry out the molecular mass determination

Processing time:
        date and time of processing
 

Fit method/model:

refers to the choice of fitting method

provides information relating to how the eluted mass was estimated (for each individual slice):

This section summarizes the molecular weight calculations for each peak selected (please refer to attached "Peak ID" graph for peak identification).

Volume:

indicates the boundaries for the selected peak (in mL or elution time)

refers to number of slices for which the MW is calculated (within the peak of interest)

value of second virial coefficient used during the analysis. The value of the second viral coefficient is negligible at the low  concentrations used during chromatographic applications.

degree of polynomial function used during the fitting protocol (1 means linear function)

used for mass estimation if a total injected mass is used instead of  depending upon the "dn/dc value + AUX constant" method

indicates the mass estimated by ASTRA within the boundaries of the particular peak

dn/dc value used for mass calculation using the RI detector signal
(dn/dc is the refractive index increment of the solute).

 Mn: Number-average molar mass defined as:

 
 

Mn is the molar mass (or molecular weight, MW); this might for instance be measured by osmometry.

 

 

Mw: Weight-average molar mass is defined as:

 

 
Mw is the molar mass (or molecular weight, MW); this might for instance be measured by light scattering method.

   

 
 

Mz: Z-average molar mass is defined as:

Rn: number-average mean square radius calculated as:


 

 Rw: weight-average mean square radius calculated as:



 
 

Rz: z-average mean square radius calculated as:


 
 

NOTE: The method for data analysis, namely, Zimm/Debye/Berry/random coil plot describes the algorithm employed by ASTRA for processing data for  EACH   INDIVIDUAL  slice.  Technically, the molar mass calculated for each slice from either of the fits (Zimm/Debye/Berry/random coil plot) is weight-averaged and the radius is z-averaged.  These masses/radii can be used together with the concentration c_i (measured with the concentration sensitive detector, UV or RI, for each slice) to find the average mass for the entire peak. Molar masses, Mn, Mw and Mz, and radius moments, Rn, Rw and Rz, represent average values obtained using different averaging formulas. The summations are performed over one peak. Please note that light scattering can be used to estimate size/radius of objects that are of the size that correspond to at least 1/20th of the incident light.  For DAWN-DSP instrument the laser wavelength is 633 nm.  Thus, radii smaller then ~ 20 nm cannot be estimated reliably.

The errors represent ONLY the statistical consistency of the data and DO NOT PROVIDE AN ABSOLUTE ERROR FOR THE ANALYSIS.  The sources of errors that are not accounted for are, for example, uncertainty in the dn/dc value, calibration constants or normalization coefficients.

 
 
 
Calculation of MW by ASTRA

Introduction to Light  Scattering	Light Scattering  Theory	Light Scattering  Data Set	Results for Standard Proteins	Light Scattering  Service	Light Scattering Front Page